Reading · a card
HonestReport
A card for anyone reading a story, paper or pitch that rests on a predicted protein structure. Print it, keep it beside you, and ask the three questions before you believe the claim.
1. "Predicted" means computed, not measured
Most structures in the AlphaFold Database are computer predictions made from a protein's sequence. An experimental structure (from X-ray crystallography, cryo-electron microscopy or NMR) is measured from real molecules. A prediction can be very accurate, but it is still a model, and it comes with its own estimate of where it might be wrong.
2. pLDDT: how sure the model is about each residue
Every residue gets a score from 0 to 100. Above 90 is very high (the backbone and most side chains are usually placed well); 70 to 90 is confident (the backbone is usually right); 50 to 70 is low; below 50 is very low and should not be read as a real shape on its own.
A low score does not mean "unimportant" or "broken". Very low stretches are often parts of the protein that are flexible or disordered in real life, and many of them do real jobs.
3. PAE: how sure the model is about where parts sit relative to each other
The predicted aligned error is a map over pairs of residues, in ångströms. Low error between two parts means the model is sure how they sit relative to each other. A model can be very sure about each folded domain and still unsure how the domains are arranged, so a claim about two distant parts needs the PAE, not just the pLDDT colours.
4. What a single-chain model leaves out
A standard AlphaFold Database entry is one protein chain on its own. It does not show partner proteins, DNA, drugs, metal ions or other small molecules bound to it, and it shows one shape where the real protein may move between several. A prediction of the normal sequence also does not show, on its own, what a mutation does.
Three questions to ask before you believe the claim
- Predicted or measured? Is the structure a computer prediction, an experiment, or both? Which entry (a UniProt or PDB code) is it?
- How sure, right where the claim is? What are the pLDDT values in the region the claim is about, and, if it is about two parts, what does the PAE say between them?
- Does the claim need something the model leaves out? A partner, a drug, a metal, a second shape, or the effect of a mutation? If so, the claim needs evidence beyond the predicted structure.
This card explains how to read a structure; it is not medical, legal or investment advice, and it cannot say whether a particular claim is true.
Sources
- AlphaFold Protein Structure Database: FAQ (EMBL-EBI)
- Jumper et al. 2021, Highly accurate protein structure prediction with AlphaFold, Nature 596:583
- Tunyasuvunakool et al. 2021, Highly accurate protein structure prediction for the human proteome, Nature 596:590
- EMBL-EBI Training: AlphaFold, a practical guide