FoldCompare · a mode
TrustCurve
AlphaFold gives every residue a confidence score, pLDDT, from 0 to 100. Is a 90 worth more than a 60? Check it against experiments: take structures measured after the predictions were public, lay each one on its prediction, and count, band by band, how many residues landed close.
the Sketcher's drawing Prediction Computed by a model, with how sure it is. Not an experiment.
the Photographer's picture Experiment Measured from real molecules.
The data: 2991 residues from 12 proteins, the BlindTest issues. A band with fewer than 30 residues says "too few to say".
Your guess first
Of the residues AlphaFold scored very high (90 and above), how many sat within 2 Å of the experiment after the two were laid on each other? (2 Å is a little more than the length of one chemical bond.)
Read it down the bands: the higher the score, the more residues land close. That is what "calibrated" means, and it is the reason to read the colours before trusting a shape.
How it is counted
- Each protein's experiment and AlphaFold DB model are paired residue by residue (UniProt numbering) and laid on each other by a least-squares fit (the Kabsch method) on the residues the model scored 70 or more.
- Each residue's distance is between its CA atoms (one per residue). Its band is the model's own pLDDT: very high 90 and above, confident 70 to 90, low 50 to 70, very low below 50.
- The proteins: Alpha-globin transcription factor CP2 (PDB 8Y7V), L-methionine gamma-lyase (PDB 9GJ9), D-aspartate oxidase (PDB 9VPF), Proton-activated chloride channel (PDB 9HQN), Antiviral protein MAP (PDB 9X2O), Transmembrane protein 164 (PDB 9LW1), Type 3 secretion system ATPase (PDB 9DMD), L-erythrulose-1-phosphate isomerase (PDB 11EF), Nudix hydrolase 11 (PDB 9NXM), T-cell antigen CD7 (PDB 12HP), Chromosomal replication initiator protein DnaA (PDB 10XE), C5a anaphylatoxin chemotactic receptor 2 (PDB 9V35).
Honest notes
- This is a handful of proteins, each a single chain, and a handful is not a survey.
- The fit uses the confident residues, which favours them a little. Crystal contacts, partners, membranes and flexible loops can move a residue for reasons that are not the model's fault.
- pLDDT scores local shape. Whether two parts sit at the right angle is what PAE describes, so a confident part can still be "far" when the whole chain is fitted at once.
- The real reference is the large-scale checks in the AlphaFold papers, done on many more structures with other measures (lDDT): Jumper et al. 2021 and Tunyasuvunakool et al. 2021.
Sources
- Jumper et al. 2021, Highly accurate protein structure prediction with AlphaFold, Nature 596:583 (what pLDDT is, and how it was checked).
- Tunyasuvunakool et al. 2021, Highly accurate protein structure prediction for the human proteome, Nature 596:590.
- Experimental structures: RCSB Protein Data Bank. Predictions: AlphaFold Protein Structure Database (CC BY 4.0).
- The superposition: Kabsch 1976, Acta Cryst. A32:922.
Snapshot 2026-10-08.